The BADgal Lash Mascara by Benefit looks great in its packaging and has a nice thick wand but I found it excessively drying on the lashes. 

It is also quite difficult to get off which may be a minus or a plus depending which way you prefer.

 

I used to always wear false lashes and it used to tak eforever to get them one right. Now I found Benefit Bad Gal lash so I can look like I have false lashes every day with out the hassle. No other mascara compares

I usually use mark.'s Make It Big mascara which has the same ovresized brush and nearly the same formula, but this came in the Spring Perk Me Up kit so I had to try it. The formula is nearly identical to mark's and although it is a great mascara, I can't see constantly spending $20 on it when I can get mark's for $6 (actualyl even cheaper since I am a rep!)

I think this is a great mascara, I actually like the huge brush! I fink it both thickens and lengthen very well. I like Benefit products and this is no exception

 
I have a whole tube that is a complete waste. My advice? Look at a sample wand before you purchase ANY mascara. The wand is way too thick for inset eyes and short lashes. You are better off using Covergirl. Don’t pay that much!

Tried this mascara based on recommendations from Benefit staff. Would NOT use again. Was very cute when used initially, created a great look, however it smudged and flaked all over after just a couple hours of wear. 

This mascara was just blah, not volumizing for me at all...it did make my lashes look longer however and gave me that weird "spidery," look

This was my HG volumizing mascara until I discovered Dior Maximeyes. Since I'm so in love with the Dior, I would not repurchase this.

 

BadGal is a great volumizing mascara. I get lush, defined lashes without the clumps.

 

My beef with this mascara is how easily it will rub off from my lashes onto my skin. I needed something that would transfer so easily.

I reallly love this mascara, and I have tried alot. It seperates but totally lengthens. W/0 clumpiniess.

I really like this mascara. I started using it about 3 weeks ago and it's done a great job. I love the huge brush. It goes on easily, never clumps, lasts all day and has not run yet and I live in the land of humidity (Florida).

Good mascara, it dosen't clump unless you put tons of it.  1 coat is enough for everyday.  I also love how almost has the same effect of my favarorite mascara, Lash Out by Dior. 

I liked the way this mascara looked on but by the end of the day I was wearing it underneath my eyes (I have oily skin).

Would I buy this again? Probably not. The brush is HUGE, in fact this is one of the largest mascara tubes I have ever seen, besides CG's Fantastic Lash. It is very easy to smudge and smear, but fortunately that doesn't happen often. Since I've discovered Max Factor's Lash Perfection, this doesn't seem to hold a candle to some of the others I have tried and like. Not a bad mascara, but for the price, I can do way better. 

I thought this mascara was really over rated. Smudged, didn't thicken. I hated it!